Catherine the Great: A Winter Book Review

Robert K. Massie’s recent bestseller, Catherine the Great, is a wonderfully engrossing tale of 18th century Russian History as experienced by one of the world’s dominant female rulers, Empress Catherine the Great.

We have been reading this book as we travel throughout New England from one frozen mountain to the next. This is certainly a winter book and as we stomp our feet in the frozen snow or curl up by a winter fire we empathize with the location of the characters of this grand book:  the frozen tundra of a winter Russia.  The backdrop for many adventures is the horse drawn sledge, pulled miles across frozen lakes and ice-covered roads.  Occupants bump about, averaging 12miles a day, as they lie huddled beneath bear furs. The winter winds rush across Russia with the same ferocity that we hear as the barren ice-covered branches of New England’s trees clack against one another and against our winter windows.

Young Catherine

In a word:  we are there.  Massie has created a portrait of Catherine the Great that provides us with a window into the very soul of Russian history.  He begins the tale when young Catherine is only 14 years old and becomes betrothed to the hapless, then adolescent, Peter III.  As a young wife, suffering under Russian Empress Elizabeth, Catherine is sequestered and prevented from loving contact with her friends and family.

Isolated, the young girl turns to books, and these become her true friends and allies. For a period of almost 12 years Catherine is prohibited from social interaction, and yet through her intellectual curiosity she is able to grow and develop and ultimately become one of the most knowledgeable and sophisticated leaders of her era.

A look at Catherine’s reading list should give us all inspiration.  Catherine read incessantly and describes herself as, “always having a book in my pocket…” Some books of particular note are the 10 volume edition of General History of Germany, and the Annals by Tacitus, a history of the Roman Empire through the reigns of Tiberius, Caligula, Claudius and Nero.  Tacitus emphasized the destruction of personal liberties by the cruelties imposed through aggressive rule. Catherine also read Montesquieu and was moved by his Enlightenment thinking.  This exposed Catherine to the ideas of a society ruled by rational thought, rather than pure power.  In addition, Voltaire was a favorite with his irreverent and witty modernistic philosophy.  As Catherine grew in intellectual and emotional maturity she was able to view some of the behaviors of the Russian court in the context of previous despotism and began to form her own more enlightened attitudes towards autocratic rule.

Massie intersperses Catherine’s own diaries throughout the book and in this way we come to know Catherine through her own voice as well as her actions.  Constant shifts in power impact Catherine and her life is filled with political upheavals, romance and desire for power.  Ultimately, through a series of astute machinations she becomes Empress Catherine and she now has the opportunity to put some of her enlightened thinking into action.  Regrettable she finds, as have so many leaders, that granting liberty and equality to the human masses is not as easy or as personally painless in practice as it is in theory.

Empress Catherine

As Empress Catherine’s power grows so does her political savvy. She begins to realize that she cannot free the Russian serfs, as she had once dreamed and that her future lies in continued actions of aggression against her neighbors.  Her motives are personal and political, tactical and geographic.  Russia needs to secure trade routes through the Baltic ocean, and therefore covets waterways and harbors belonging to other nations.  Catherine finds that her continued aggression in the region wins her foreign accolades as she is triumphant in battle after battle.

As reader we are placed in the uncomfortable position of watching an unchecked leader exercise total power over her hapless subjects despite her initial best attempts at Enlightenment Thinking.  At all costs, Catherine sees that she must protect herself and the ruling class.

Liberté, égalité, fraternité

This fascinating story of the late 1700’s is a tale which effects us all.  The revolutionary thinking of the times, beginning with our own American Revolution, the resulting French Revolution and ultimately the demise of the British throne had seeds which were sown in the great mistreatment and inequality of the vast majority of the proletariat.  Enlightenment thinking and satiric philosophers also paved the way for new thinking: Words do have the power to effect great change.

Catherine the Great covers each of these uprisings and we can understand them both from the perspective of the people as well as from the monarchies the people sought to overthrow.

Russia in 1725

One of the great joys of this book is to follow the action on a map and to see how the countries borders were constantly being redrawn.  It is fascinating to understand the diplomatic reasoning behind tactical acquisitions and to see how the ordinary person was constantly expected to realign themselves with a new governing body.

It is also interesting to see the way religious lines are drawn, almost by the map, as battle-lines are drawn between Lutheran, Catholic and Orthodox believers.  The late 1700’s were a time of deep faith among Christians, and yet that deep faith did not yield greater understanding, tolerance or Christian love for one another.

We really recommend this book to anyone who loves a great tale, enjoys romance and intrigue, is intellectually curious about the philosophers of the 18th century and loves history and geography.  Suggestion:  Read this book on a cold winter’s day by a warm fire while the snow is falling thickly and the logs are burning crisply.

Follow-up reading:  A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens.  This intertwined tale of love, politics and social inequality, gives a unique insiders view to the guillotine and the French Revolution.

Let Me Count the Days:  Homeschooling is admitting that 300 years ago people were better educated than they are today.   

14 Responses

  1. This looks like such a great book. I have it on my to read list. Thanks for such a wonderful review, well written.

    • I have spoken to many people who have really enjoyed this book. It is highly readable and informative while providing thought-provoking entertainment. I look forward to hearing your thoughts.

      Allia

  2. Massie’s book is terribly flawed, beginning with author’s inability to read Russian, which he modestly fails to mnetion. It is full of errors, and there are several much better books, those by
    de Madariaga,
    Dixon, and
    alexander, to be precise.
    They all read
    Russian and know
    russian history. Massie congratulates himself on ignoring the salacious stories about
    catherine’s sex life, apparently unaware that these are all over the Interet for the past two decades. He is now 82 and has obiously lost it, as confirmed by his pathetic performance on
    charle
    Rose a few weeks ago. Has the man no shame?

    • Thank you for contributing authors that present a more accurate picture of Russian history. None the less, I found this book highly readable and enjoyable. I am much more interested in the political and philosophical thinking of the day than I am in Catherine’s sexual exploits. Catherine’s influence, both positive and negative, on Russia, her neighbors and on Europe was significant and can not be discounted by criticizing her personal behavior. I am also not sure how accurate “two decades of internet information” is regarding a woman who lived 300 years ago. I appreciate your contribution as you have certainly offered a different perspective on Robert K. Massie’s book.

      Allia

  3. This looks like a great read! I’ll have to put it on my list. Thanks for posting!

    Darlena

  4. Also read this recently. Found it interesting that her espousal of Voltaire’s philosophy took a light-speed back-pedal after she dealt with the uprisings of the serfs.

    I’ve wondered about Massie’s fawning portrayal of Catherine – just a quick Internet search turns up much less flattering impressions of her.

    That is some bookshelf, btw . Nice.

    • It is a fascinating book and certainly colored by Massie’s fictionalized account. It is unfortunate indeed to see how quickly she gave up on freeing the serfs, although I believe her grandson did ultimately get around to freeing them. Sometimes change takes several generations, unfortunately.

      Allia

      • nOT A FASCINATING READ BECAUSE IT IS FULL OF ERRORS! Massie cannot read Russian. That should tell you something! Her grandson did notfree the serfs.
        That only began in 1861! Massie would’t know!

      • I have to agree with you. Alexander I, Catherine’s grandson, tried to free the serfs but later reneged. It was actually Alexander II that freed them in 1861. None the less, the book does offer insight into the Russian court and provides a certain, if imperfect, historical view on the times.

        Allia

  5. Oh, I’ve been wanting to read this and am glad to know that it is so readable. Thanks for posting the review!

  6. I tend to agree with you. This book indeed is readable and enjoyable, despite numerous mistakes ( I am not talking about her personal life, however some of her favorites became prominent political figures in Russian history ). I hope this book will inspire people to dig deeper, after all that is what bibliography is for, isn’t?

    • You are correct. That is exactly the point of a bibliography – to make the reader curious enough to dig deeper into the topic, in effect to do their own research. We cannot expect one book to provide all the answers and all the perspectives on a complicated topic. Thank you for your comment.

      Allia

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: